Home PoliticsPrivate DNA test cannot disprove child’s legitimacy: LHC

Private DNA test cannot disprove child’s legitimacy: LHC

by PNN Author

The Lahore High Court (LHC) has ruled that a privately arranged DNA test cannot override the legal presumption of a child’s legitimacy when the child is born during a valid marriage, upholding a maintenance award against a father living in the United Kingdom (UK).

Justice Asad Ali Bajwa issued the ruling while hearing a petition filed by Osama Tahir against decisions of a Gujranwala family court and an additional district and sessions judge concerning maintenance, dowry articles and other claims filed by his wife Zainab Irfan, and their minor son.

The couple married on Aug 18, 2019, and had two sons. According to the case their relationship initially remained cordial before the husband allegedly expelled his wife and younger son from the matrimonial home. The older boy remained with his paternal grandparents.

The family court partly accepted the wife’s suit and ordered the father to pay Rs10,000 per month in maintenance for the minor. An additional district and sessions judge later increased the amount to Rs25,000 per month, with a 10 percent annual increase.

The appellate court also awarded the wife Rs12,000 per month for the iddat period and ordered the return of dowry articles or payment of their alternative value of Rs970,000.

The father disowned the younger child and presented a DNA test conducted at a laboratory in the UK, which reported that paternity was excluded. However, Justice Bajwa noted that the family court had rejected his claim.

The judge held that Article 128 of the Qanun-i-Shahadat Order, 1984 which establishes the legitimacy of a child born during a valid marriage unless the husband refuses to acknowledge the child.

He also noted that the father’s own witnesses admitted that the marriage remained intact when the child was born and that the father and his mother accompanied the wife to the hospital.

“A unilateral DNA test report cannot by itself displace the conclusive presumption of legitimacy provided under Article 128 of the Qanun-i-Shahadat Order, 1984,” the judge observed.

He said that courts must approach DNA testing with caution and prioritise the child’s welfare.

The wife claimed that her husband earned Rs1.2 million a month in the UK. Although she provided no documentary evidence of his income, the judge noted that the father’s witnesses confirmed his residence in the UK and that he sent money into a family bank account.

Justice Bajwa held that the evidence supported the wife’s claim of her husband’s earnings abroad and that he failed to establish that the enhanced maintenance amount was excessive.

He stated that maintenance must account for the child’s needs, including food, clothing, accommodation, education and healthcare, as well as the father’s financial means and earning capacity.

The judge also held that responsibility may shift to the paternal grandfather only if the father lacks the means and cannot earn.

You may also like

Leave a Comment